Review: I’ll Cry Tomorrow (1955)

>> Sunday, June 21, 2009

USA/B&W-117m./Dir: Daniel Mann/Wr: Helen Deutsch & Jay Richard Kennedy/Cast: Susan Hayward (Lillian Roth), Jo Van Fleet (Katie Roth), Richard Conte (Tony Bardeman), Eddie Albert (Burt McGuire), Don Taylor (Wallie), Ray Danton (David Treadman)

I’ll Cry Tomorrow is one of the booziest biopics ever produced by Hollywood. Based on the autobiography of singer and professed alcoholic Lillian Roth, this glossy melodrama wastes little time on Roth’s rise to stardom and focuses almost entirely on the songbird’s downward spiral into alcoholism, depression, alcoholism, bad marriage, alcoholism, despair, and alcoholism. A more accurate title would have been I’ll Cry Tomorrow, But I’ll Drink Today.

The sensationalized account of Lillian Roth’s life provided a perfect vehicle for MGM’s queen of melodrama, Susan Hayward. As the soused songstress, Hayward was given the opportunity to indulge in the overwrought style of acting in which she specialized. Whether wallowing in self pity, belting out song lyrics, tossing back slugs of whiskey, or suffering shivering fits of delirium tremens, the actress earned her Academy Award nomination by giving her all in every scene. Admittedly, by today’s standards Hayward’s “all” is a bit too much. Her extremely theatrical style of acting often pushes the film in the direction of camp; and some scenes play out like a Carol Burnett Show parody of a 50’s melodrama rather than a serious depiction of addiction.

Despite Hayward’s histrionic performance (or perhaps because of it), I’ll Cry Tomorrow is a very entertaining biopic painted in silky shades of black and white. It is professionally directed, well acted (and overacted), beautifully shot, and the musical numbers are well staged. The worst that can be said for the film is that it suffers some of the problems that plague all biopics--the nagging feeling that a documentary featuring the real subject would have made a more interesting movie and the artificiality of having a single performer portray several decades of an individual’s life (the 38-year-old Hayward, while well preserved, comes off a bit ridiculous portraying Roth as a teenager).

Ultimately, I’ll Cry Tomorrow is a worthy addition to the booze movie subgenre of addiction and recovery films, such as The Lost Weekend (1945) and Days of Wine and Roses (1962). Whether you choose to watch I’ll Cry Tomorrow for its depiction of alcoholism as a disease or simply view it for its camp value, it delivers big on both counts.

Drinks Consumed--Whiskey, martinis (gin), champagne, wine, and unnamed cocktails.

Intoxicating Effects--Slurred speech, staggering, stumbling, sneaking sips, the giggles, bickering, brawling, physical violence, public disturbance, passing out, memory blackouts, the shakes, and delirium tremens

Potent Quotables--LILLIAN (narration): Every nerve in my body was screaming. I couldn’t believe this was happening to me. All I had to do was open that door and walk ten steps to the bar in my living room to find relief from this torture. Nothing could have that hold on me. I had to face it, confront it. It was the only way. I could, and I had to… I took the drink I didn’t want to take.

Video Availability--I’ll Cry Tomorrow is available as a standalone DVD or as part of The Leading Ladies Collection, Vol. 2 (Warner Brothers).

Similarly Sauced Cinema--Susan Hayward received her first Academy Award nomination playing another sauce-slugging songbird in Smash Up: The Story of a Woman (1947).

I'll Cry Tomorrow (CD featuring the real Lillian Roth)


Otto Mannix June 26, 2009 at 1:34 PM  

Hilarious website. Please check out the movie SOME CAME RUNNING, with Frank Sinatra and Dean Martin. The booze flows freely in that 1950s classic!

garv June 26, 2009 at 5:49 PM  

I'm glad you like the site. Click on the "follow" button if you want regular updates. I usually post something once a week (occasionally more).

I'm a huge Dino fan, so I love SOME CAME RUNNING. Its the best pairing of Rat Packers Frank and Dean on film. I plan to review it eventually for the site. Thanks for visiting.

Otto Mannix June 26, 2009 at 6:42 PM  

i have your site listed on my blog. i'm big into "It's A Gift". It's in my top ten movies ever. check out my strange blog. it sort of wanders in various directions, but i like to think it has a certain tone.

Shelly July 20, 2009 at 8:34 PM  

I enjoyed your review of I'll Cry Tomorrow. Susan Hayward certainly had an acting range beyond melodrama, but it was in these parts that she achieved the most success. She made another boozey film called Smash-Up. I believe it is in Smash-Up that she meets an AA member in the person of Eddie Albert. It's been awhile, and this might be the wrong movie, but I do remember a vivid scene where she sort of stumbles into AA and Eddie (friend of Bill W.) helps her on the road to recovery.

garv July 20, 2009 at 9:36 PM  


Thanks for stopping by. I also enjoyed Smash Up, and yes, it did also co-star Eddie Albert. You can find my review of Smash Up: The Story of a Woman by clicking on the link under "Similarly Sauced Cinema" or by using the Movie Reviews menu on the left.


468X60 RENTAL - James Stewart Animated Gif (44kb)

About Me

My photo
I like to drink. I like to watch movies. I like to watch movies about drinking. I like to write about the movies I’ve watched, but only if I’ve had a drink first.

All text including the title "Booze Movies: The 100 Proof Film Guide" Copyright William T. Garver

  © Blogger templates Romantico by 2008

Back to TOP